Skip to main content

Simple Ways To Measure Stock Valuation Using Company's Earnings

Investing in stocks is quite risky if we don't do proper analysis. Stock prices can go up and down at any time. Even sometimes prices can go very low without any clear reason.

One way to minimize the risk is by investing in mispriced stocks, i.e. stocks that are priced lower than their actual value (undervalued), rather than picking stocks only because of hype or positive trend. This strategy is often called value investing.

The term value investing was first introduced by Benjamin Graham (the mentor of arguably the most successful and well-known investor of all time, Warren Buffet) and David Dodd in the 1920s. By investing in an undervalued stock, we expect the price to return to its fair price one day, so we will be less worried when it goes down. A lower price can even become an opportunity for us to buy more.

Some Simple Valuation Methods Using Earnings

There are various methods to measure stock valuation. Some of the simpler ways are involving the company's earnings, such as:

1. PE Ratio

PE (Price to Earnings) Ratio is defined as a ratio of current stock price to its earnings per share (EPS). The lower the PE Ratio, the more undervalued the stock is. Personally, I often look for stocks with a PE Ratio between 0-15. I also consider a PE Ratio below 6 as undervalued. We can find PE Ratio data on many stock market platforms like Yahoo Finance or Wall Street Journal.

Note that a PE Ratio can be negative. It means the company is not profitable yet (negative earnings). In that case, the PE Ratio is irrelevant.

Example:
We will use Dell Technologies Inc. (ticker symbol DELL) as an example.


The above picture is taken from Yahoo Finance. We can see that the PE ratio (TTM) of DELL is 6.10. By the way, TTM is Trailing 12 Months, which means the EPS data is taken from the last 12 consecutive months.

Using my standard, DELL can be considered a stock with a very good PE Ratio, and even almost undervalued.

2. Relative PE Ratio

Previously, we measured the valuation by just looking at the stock's PE Ratio and made assumptions on how good it is.

This relative PE Ratio method is slightly different. Here, we want to compare the PE Ratio to the others.

Example:
We know that DELL's PE Ratio is 6.10. Now we will look at HPQ and IBM, which run similar business.



The PE Ratios of IBM and HPQ are 21.41 and 5.75. This means, DELL is more undervalued compared to IBM, but more overvalued compared to HPQ. Another way to measure it is by looking at more competitors and taking the average PE Ratio of all those companies as a benchmark.

3. PEG Ratio

PEG Ratio is a ratio of current stock price to the company's earnings growth. Like PE Ratio, we look for a lower value. This method requires an assumption on the expected rate of earning growth. We can also use historical earning growth in the last few years to predict future growth.

Personally, I like to be a little bit more conservative by applying a 30% discount to historical growth. Below is the formula I use to calculate PEG. I consider a stock undervalued if its PEG ratio is between 0-1.

\begin{equation} PEG=\frac{PE\ Ratio}{Historical\ growth\ rate*0.7} \end{equation}

The average historical earning growth can be calculated using CAGR calculator by putting the initial and final EPS.

Example:
Currently, DELL has a 6.10 PE Ratio. We can then look at its income statement in Yahoo Finance to get the initial and final EPS for our growth rate calculation.


We can see that in 3 years (from 2018 to 2021), DELL's EPS has grown from 3.30 to 5.38. Putting those values in the CAGR calculator, we get the following growth rate.


Now, we will use this growth rate and the PE Ratio into my equation, we get the following PEG Ratio.

\begin{equation} PEG=\frac{6.10}{17.69*0.7}=0.49 \end{equation}

Based on the result, DELL is undervalued for me.

4. Eddy Elfenbein's Valuation

This method was published in his article: http://www.crossingwallstreet.com/archives/2012/05/worlds-simplest-stock-valuation-measure.html. It is quite interesting. Notice that in the previous valuation method using PEG, we have 1 issue. If the company's earnings were not growing, either 0 growth or negative growth, the method would be irrelevant.

Eddy Elfenbein's valuation formula can address this issue. He assumes we can buy a zero growth company at a PE Ratio of 8. Therefore, he proposed the following formula to calculate the fair PE Ratio.

\begin{equation} PE\ Ratio=\frac{Growth\ rate}{2}+8 \end{equation}

If we had zero or even negative earning growth, we could still have a positive PE Ratio.

In this method, after having the fair PE Ratio, we can then calculate the stock fair price by multiplying the PE Ratio to the expected next year EPS. Usually companies publish their earnings forecasts for the next year. We can use those values.

However, if for whatever reason we decided not to use the earnings forecasts, we can use the expected growth rate to calculate next year's EPS using this simple formula

\begin{equation}  EPS=(1+Growth\ rate\ in\ decimal) * Current\ EPS \end{equation}

In summary, I will extend Eddy Elfenbein's formula as follows to get a stock fair price, in case we didn't use the company's released earnings forecast.

\begin{equation}  Fair\ Price=(\frac{Growth\ rate}{2}+8)*(1+Growth\ rate\ in\ decimal) * Current\ EPS \end{equation}

Just like Eddy Elfenbein, I usually also look for stocks that are 30% below their fair price. This 30% value is often called Margin of Safety. This concept was popularized by Benjamin Graham.

Example:
We will use (17.69*0.7) of expected growth rate for DELL like the previous example.
Now let's say DELL released its earnings forecast for next year at 7.50. We will get the following PE Ratio.

\begin{equation} PE\ Ratio=\frac{17.69*0.7}{2}+8=14.1915 \end{equation}

Multiplying it to the earning forecast, we get:

\begin{equation} Fair\ Price=14.1915*7.05=100.05 \end{equation}

Then, after adding a margin of safety of 30%, we get 70.03. That means the current price of DELL, 41.43, is way undervalued based on this method.

As for alternative, we will calculate using my equation. Recall the previous data from Yahoo Finance, we know DELL's EPS (TTM) is 6.79. Plugging those values into the equation will give us:

\begin{equation} Fair\ Price=(\frac{17.69*0.7}{2}+8)*(1+(0.1769*0.7)) * 6.79=108.2925 \end{equation}

After adding a margin of safety of 30%, we get 75.80.

Conclusion

Those are some relatively simple methods we can use to measure stock value. You can combine all of those methods for better insight. There are a lot of other valuation methods we can use. Some of the most popular ones are Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) method, Peter Lynch's valuation method, and also Dividend Discount Model (DDM), which are a little bit more complex than the above methods.

Please also remember that a good stock is not only determined by its valuation. There are a lot of things we must consider, like how the business is run, the competitors, the dividend, the cash flow, and many others. But, understanding the valuation can at least prevent us from investing in overvalued stocks, which have more possibility to go down towards their fair price.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Time Relativity: Can You Travel into The Future?

Can you travel into the future? To answer this question, we need to understand the concept of time relativity. According to Einstein, time is relative. Every object has its own time. The rate at which time passes for me might be different from the rate at which time passes for you. What is Relativity?  Imagine you are inside a flying airplane. For someone standing on earth, he will see that you are moving along with the airplane at a particular speed. While from your perspective, you are actually at rest. This might be counterintuitive because you know you are definitely moving along with the airplane. However, we are talking about the airplane's point of view, not the earth's point of view. Try to close your eyes when you are inside an airplane. You will feel that you are not moving at all. Another example: suppose there are two cars, A and B, moving in opposite directions at the same speed. Someone on the ground can observe that A and B are moving at the same speed, let's

Psychopath Test: Can You Think Like A Psychopath?

Psychopathy is a mental disorder. It is often informally described as ASPD (Antisocial Personality Disorder). Psychopaths often possess some common traits, such as a lack of emotional responses, a lack of empathy, impulsivity, and having a tendency to show antisocial behavior. In fact, most research agrees that around 1% of the population is psychopathic. Are you one of them? or do you have the potential to become one? Below are some questions we can use to see if we have the capability to think like a psychopath. In each of these questions, don't give the first answer that comes to your mind. Try to think like a psychopath as hard as you can! QUESTION 1 You were a middle-aged man. You had a nephew. One day, he had his birthday. At night, when he'd already fallen asleep, you came to his house and left him a birthday present, a brand new expensive bicycle, wrapped in a box. The next morning, he woke up and felt very happy after knowing you gave him the present. Then, he opened t